The first part of this analysis, Offensive Archetypes, sorted nearly a decade of rotation-caliber players into 9 offensive roles using a model built entirely on in-game tendencies -- what a player does, not how well they do it. That left one obvious question unanswered: which players are actually good at their role? This article answers that, with a formula for each archetype that now scores players based on volume and efficiency rather than tendency.

A Quick Recap: The 9 Archetypes

Archetype What they tend to do
Shot Creator Dribble-heavy, pull-up scoring that's mostly unassisted
Spot Up Spacer Lowest usage of any archetype, catch-and-shoot heavy, almost all assisted
Movement Shooter Off-screen and handoff possessions, high 3PT share, stays out of the paint
Inside Out Big Roll man / cutter / screener with an added catch-and-shoot wrinkle
Utility Big Moderate interior touches and screen assists, no single standout trait
Initiator Highest usage of any archetype -- elite drive volume, isolation reps, fouls drawn
Rim Runner Dunks, cuts, offensive rebounding, shortest average shot distance
Mid-Post Creator Post touches, mid-range, and real passing -- the "do-everything" tier
Post Anchor The single most extreme feature in the whole model -- post-touch volume well above everyone else

How the Ranking Works

Each archetype gets its own weighted formula, scoring players only against others in their own archetype. Every formula follows the same structure: volume/production stats outweigh efficiency stats, which outweigh role-specific stats (based on the archetype tendencies found in the initial analysis), which outweigh availability (minutes and games played). This is designed to try to prevent cases where an efficient low-volume player scores higher than a high-volume producer.

The formulas are created based on each archetype's defining cluster features from the Offensive Archetypes analysis. A Shot Creator's formula weights assists, pull-up makes, and drive-and-kick passing the heaviest, because that's what separates Shot Creators from one another. A Post Anchor's formula weights post-up scoring and screens set, because that's what separates post players from each other. Every feature gets standardized within that player's own archetype and season, so a 2016-17 Spot Up Spacer is only ever measured against other 2016-17 Spot Up Spacers -- never against a different season or a different role.

See the full formula for each archetype

Every stat below is z-scored within the player's own archetype and season before being weighted -- the numbers in these tables are the weights of each stat (how much each stat counts), not the stats themselves. Again, tiers follow the same hierarchy in every formula: volume/production outweighs efficiency, which outweighs role-based stats, which outweighs availability.

Shot Creator

StatWeightTier
Assists0.16Volume/production
Pull-up jump shot makes0.13Volume/production
Drive-and-kick passes0.10Volume/production
Points scored0.09Volume/production
Pick-and-roll ball-handler scoring0.08Volume/production
3-point makes0.07Volume/production
Isolation scoring0.07Volume/production
Assist rate0.06Efficiency
High-dribble pull-up efficiency0.05Efficiency
Assist-to-turnover ratio0.04Efficiency
Pick-and-roll ball-handler efficiency0.03Efficiency
Mid-range pull-up efficiency0.02Efficiency
3-point percentage0.02Efficiency
Isolation efficiency0.01Efficiency
Handoff efficiency0.01Efficiency
Minutes per game0.04Availability
Games played0.02Availability

Utility Big

StatWeightTier
Post-up scoring0.15Volume/production
Screens set0.11Volume/production
Pick-and-roll roll-man scoring0.10Volume/production
Offensive rebounds0.09Volume/production
Cut makes0.08Volume/production
Dunk makes0.07Volume/production
Fouls drawn0.06Volume/production
Post-up efficiency0.05Efficiency
Offensive rebound rate0.05Efficiency
Pick-and-roll roll-man efficiency0.04Efficiency
Interior 2-point finishing0.03Efficiency
Cut efficiency0.02Efficiency
Post touch volume0.04Role confirmation
Elbow touch volume0.03Role confirmation
Paint touch volume0.02Role confirmation
Minutes per game0.04Availability
Games played0.02Availability

Rim Runner

StatWeightTier
Dunk makes0.14Volume/production
Screens set0.13Volume/production
Offensive rebounds0.11Volume/production
Cut scoring0.11Volume/production
Layup makes0.09Volume/production
Offensive rebound rate0.07Efficiency
Layup conversion rate0.06Efficiency
Dunk efficiency0.05Efficiency
Interior 2-point finishing0.04Efficiency
Pick-and-roll roll-man efficiency0.03Efficiency
Cut efficiency0.01Efficiency
Paint touch volume0.05Role confirmation
Elbow touch volume0.03Role confirmation
Post touch volume0.02Role confirmation
Minutes per game0.04Availability
Games played0.02Availability

Initiator

StatWeightTier
Assists0.16Volume/production
Drives to the basket0.13Volume/production
Fouls drawn0.11Volume/production
Drive-and-kick passes0.10Volume/production
Points scored0.08Volume/production
Isolation scoring0.07Volume/production
Pick-and-roll ball-handler scoring0.07Volume/production
Assist rate0.06Efficiency
Mid-range pull-up efficiency0.06Efficiency
High-dribble efficiency0.05Efficiency
Isolation efficiency0.03Efficiency
Post-up efficiency0.01Efficiency
Pick-and-roll ball-handler efficiency0.01Efficiency
Minutes per game0.04Availability
Games played0.02Availability

Movement Shooter

StatWeightTier
3-point makes0.15Volume/production
Off-screen makes0.14Volume/production
Handoff makes0.11Volume/production
Jump shot attempts0.10Volume/production
Corner-3 makes0.08Volume/production
Spot-up scoring0.07Volume/production
Off-screen efficiency0.06Efficiency
3-point percentage0.06Efficiency
Handoff efficiency0.05Efficiency
Spot-up efficiency0.04Efficiency
Transition efficiency0.02Efficiency
Off-ball movement speed0.06Role confirmation
Minutes per game0.04Availability
Games played0.02Availability

Post Anchor

StatWeightTier
Post-up scoring0.17Volume/production
Screens set0.12Volume/production
Fouls drawn0.10Volume/production
Interior 2-point makes0.09Volume/production
Free throw makes0.07Volume/production
Post-up efficiency0.06Efficiency
Offensive rebound rate0.06Efficiency
Pick-and-roll roll-man efficiency0.05Efficiency
Interior 2-point finishing0.04Efficiency
Short pull-up efficiency0.02Efficiency
Playmaking out of the post0.02Efficiency
Post touch volume0.05Role confirmation
Elbow touch volume0.05Role confirmation
Paint touch volume0.04Role confirmation
Minutes per game0.04Availability
Games played0.02Availability

Spot Up Spacer

StatWeightTier
Corner-3 makes0.20Volume/production
3-point makes0.17Volume/production
Catch-and-shoot makes0.14Volume/production
Jump shot attempts0.11Volume/production
Spot-up scoring0.08Volume/production
3-point percentage0.06Efficiency
Catch-and-shoot effective FG%0.06Efficiency
Spot-up points per possession0.06Efficiency
Transition efficiency0.04Efficiency
Off-screen efficiency0.02Efficiency
Minutes per game0.04Availability
Games played0.02Availability

Inside Out Big

StatWeightTier
Pick-and-roll roll-man scoring0.13Volume/production
Dunk makes0.12Volume/production
Screens set0.10Volume/production
Cut makes0.08Volume/production
Offensive rebounds0.08Volume/production
Total rebounds0.07Volume/production
3-point makes0.07Volume/production
Pick-and-roll roll-man efficiency0.06Efficiency
Offensive rebound rate0.05Efficiency
Dunk efficiency0.04Efficiency
Catch-and-shoot effective FG%0.04Efficiency
Layup conversion rate0.03Efficiency
Post-up efficiency0.02Efficiency
Cut efficiency0.01Efficiency
Paint touch volume0.04Role confirmation
Minutes per game0.04Availability
Games played0.02Availability

Mid-Post Creator

StatWeightTier
Post-up scoring0.14Volume/production
Fouls drawn0.11Volume/production
Interior 2-point makes0.10Volume/production
Isolation scoring0.07Volume/production
Points scored0.07Volume/production
Mid-range makes0.06Volume/production
Assists0.06Volume/production
Post-up efficiency0.05Efficiency
Assist rate0.05Efficiency
Mid-range pull-up efficiency0.05Efficiency
Interior 2-point finishing0.03Efficiency
Isolation efficiency0.03Efficiency
Off-screen efficiency0.03Efficiency
Post touch volume0.05Role confirmation
Elbow touch volume0.04Role confirmation
Minutes per game0.04Availability
Games played0.02Availability

Two final scores get saved, both 0-100:

The season-specific score is the one that matters for "who's having the best year?" This is the score that the rest of the article uses as well.

One thing worth noting before results: every score below only scores players in their specific archetype (from the Offensive Archetypes article) and only compares the players to others assigned to that same archetype that season. Because of this, there may be players that aren't scored in a specific archetype, even though their game might fit or excel in that role. Steph Curry is the clearest example -- he's classified as an Initiator every season in this analysis, so that's the only archetype he's eligible to get a score for. But when scoring him in the other formulas, Curry would grade as high as 100.0 as a Movement Shooter (2018-19) and 98.7 as a Spot Up Spacer the same season -- both higher than most players actually assigned to those archetypes that year. The archetype label is just a classification based on his tendencies each season, not a ceiling on how talented or versatile the player is; more on this in the Limitations section below.

The Best Seasons on Record, By Archetype

This table shows the players that achieved a score of 100 in the OFF_SCORE metric, indicating they were the best player in that archetype across all seasons that were analyzed. Again, players are only scored in the archetype they were classified as. Giannis may have been the best at rim-running, but if he was classified as a Post Anchor, then he won't get a score for Rim Runner.

Archetype Best Player x Season
Initiator Russell Westbrook, 2016-17
Shot Creator Darius Garland, 2021-22
Movement Shooter Malik Beasley, 2024-25
Spot Up Spacer Danny Green, 2018-19
Rim Runner Rudy Gobert, 2016-17
Utility Big Nikola Jokić, 2016-17
Inside Out Big Donovan Clingan, 2025-26
Mid-Post Creator Giannis Antetokounmpo, 2024-25
Post Anchor Nikola Jokić, 2024-25

2025-26 Leaders, By Archetype

Archetype 2025-26 leader
Initiator Shai Gilgeous-Alexander
Shot Creator Donovan Mitchell
Movement Shooter Nickeil Alexander-Walker
Spot Up Spacer Sam Merrill
Rim Runner Rudy Gobert
Utility Big Jusuf Nurkić
Inside Out Big Donovan Clingan
Mid-Post Creator Luka Dončić
Post Anchor Nikola Jokić

This is a good sanity check on the formulas themselves -- Jokić leading Post Anchors and Shai Gilgeous-Alexander leading Initiators are who most NBA fans would expect to see there. On the other hand, Donovan Clingan being the top Inside Out Big is a bit of a surprise, as he isn't necessarily known for having the outside game, though he did extend his range this previous season.

Just for some additional context, archetypes have varying degrees of success and talent in their player pool. Post Anchor has both the highest average score (51.8) and the tightest spread (std. dev. 16.5) of any archetype -- there are only 202 true post-up bigs in ten seasons, indicating the ones who still play that way tend to excel in that role. Shot Creator, the most common archetype at 824 player-seasons, has one of the widest spreads (std. dev. 21.1), since that role covers everyone from All-NBA guards to end-of-bench guys.

Versatility vs. Specialization

When scoring every player x season combo in all 9 formulas, not just their own assigned archetype, it is easy to see which players are specialists and which players can take on various responsibilities.

The versatile players. Using a threshold of scoring 70+ (on the 0-100 within-season scale) to be considered "elite," Nikola Jokić grades elite in 7 of the 9 archetype formulas this past season. Giannis Antetokounmpo is elite in 6. This is the data-supported version of the scouting report for these players: basically no weaknesses, impossible to stop them on offense.

The specialists. Some players have a huge gap between their own archetype score and how they'd score everywhere else. Neemias Queta and Rudy Gobert both score 90+ as Rim Runners while averaging barely 40 across the other 8 archetypes -- elite at one thing, and don't expect them to stray from that. This isn't necessarily a bad thing, as Rudy Gobert has had a successful career setting screens and rolling to the rim. Shai Gilgeous-Alexander shows the same pattern from the perimeter: a 98.4 as an Initiator against a 54.1 average everywhere else. His game is predicated on getting himself (and others) good shots off the dribble. This playstyle has led to back-to-back MVPs for Shai.

An interesting but not very surprising note is Jokić showing up in both groups at once -- the single most versatile offensive player in the dataset by cross-archetype score, and also the best at his own archetype specifically.

Note: these charts plot OFF_SCORE_SZN -- a player's score within whichever archetype they were actually classified as that season, not a blend of all 9 formulas. When a player's archetype changed, the line keeps going, but the formula being applied changed underneath it.

Shai Gilgeous-Alexander's rise. SGA's within-season score has gone 45.1 → 54.4 → 91.3 → 90.0 → 98.9 → 100.0 → 100.0 → 100.0 from his second season through 2025-26, including a reclassification from Shot Creator to Initiator as his usage increased. This shows his historic, unexpected rise, and it also calls for a Chris Paul shoutout since he played with Shai in Shai's second season.

Shai Gilgeous-Alexander -- archetype score by season

Nikola Jokić's sustained peak. In 2017-18, Jokić took on the role of Post Anchor, switching from a Utility Big role. In 2020-21, he became the best Post Anchor in the league and has held that title for 6 years straight.

Nikola Jokić -- archetype score by season

Jalen Brunson's role change. Brunson classified as a Shot Creator from 2018-19 through 2020-21, then shifted to Initiator from 2021-22 onward as his role changed with the Knicks. His score increased from 58.3 to a peak of 92.0 in 2024-25, before dropping to 76.0 in 2025-26 -- a real dip worth watching, though Mike Brown changed the offensive scheme, so Brunson was not relied upon as heavily as an Initiator. This also shows potential limitations of this analysis, since Brunson just had his most successful season and won Finals MVP. The decrease in his score is simply a reflection of his game not fitting entirely into the Initiator role and formula this past season.

Jalen Brunson -- archetype score by season

Look Up Any Player

Limitations and What's Missing

The formulas are based on the initial analysis, but they are influenced by my own opinion on things like how the weighting should work. The weights (why assists get 0.16 for a Shot Creator while 3-point makes get 0.07) are judgment calls that were tweaked multiple times in the creation of this analysis. There is no strict right-or-wrong answer to how these formulas should be built.

Other limitations worth mentioning:

The Takeaway

Evaluating players within their role is one of the most difficult and also important jobs in sports. This article uses archetype-specific formulas to score players across 9 offensive archetypes in the NBA. The results mostly pass the eye test: Jokić and SGA on top of their respective archetypes, specialists and versatile players showing up where they should, etc. The formulas are a mix of analysis and opinions, not objective truth. Looking at roster breakdowns by archetype is the next step -- see Team Construction and Success by Offensive Archetype for what these same archetypes and scores look like at the team level, and find out if there is any correlation between archetypes and team success.