We've all heard the age-old saying "defense wins championships." As the game has evolved, defense has gotten harder to measure. Do you look at points allowed per possession? Defensive rating? Steals, blocks, or deflections? Is defense simply an eye-test to see if they make the offensive player's life difficult? This article explores various ways of measuring defense, identifies the best defenders, and acknowledges any limitations that simply looking at data has.
Two Main Ways to Measure a Stop
For the first half of the article, we will look strictly at the 2025-2026 season, pulling data for all players who qualified on the defensive end.
The first dataset pulled is a full season of individual matchups -- every time a defender was the primary man guarding a given offensive player and how many points came out of it. Sum that across a season and you get points allowed per 100 matchup possessions. In simple terms, it answers "how often does this guy actually get scored on when he's the assignment?"
The second dataset used is shot-tracking: every shot a defender contests, and how often the offensive player makes it. That gives FG% suppression -- the gap between an offensive player's normal percentage and what they actually shot with this specific defender guarding them. Primary defenders of star players may get scored on a lot, but if they hold that star to 5% worse than his average, should this be considered a success?
A defender can be excellent at one and struggle at the other. Kentavious Caldwell-Pope ranked top-15 in the league in points allowed per 100 possessions last season -- but shooters he closely guards actually shoot better than their normal percentage against him (-6.1% suppression, below the league average). This could mean that Caldwell-Pope deters opponents from shooting unless they have a great look, or he could just be guarding role players who don't get many opportunities on their team's offensive system.
The Leaderboard (2025-2026)
Combining both stats together -- minimum 1,500 matchup possessions and 4 shots defended per game to qualify, 337 players clear that bar -- here are the top 20 by points allowed per 100 possessions, with their FG% suppression alongside it.
(League averages across the qualified pool of defenders: 47.2% FG allowed, 24.2 Pts/100, and essentially 0% suppression. Positive suppression means shooters do worse than their own normal percentage against that defender.)
Looking at the Top 20 by PTS/100 list, Amen Thompson allowed the least points per 100 possessions and also suppresses shooters above the league average (+4.3%) -- an agreement which gives Thompson a case for best perimeter defender in the league. Caldwell-Pope, Norman Powell, and Gary Trent Jr. all post good matchup numbers while actively making shooters better. The reverse happens too, with defenders whose shot-contesting is elite but whose overall matchup efficiency is middling.
This list contains a mix of star players, young bench guys, and veteran role players. One thing that isn't taken into account here is matchup quality. Amen Thompson most likely took on the main offensive option every night, whereas a two-way player like Caleb Love was mostly matched up with other bench players in his time on the court.
When switching to Top 20 by FG% Suppression, we see many interior 4s and 5s that protect the paint and alter shots at the rim. Victor Wembanyama and Clint Capela lead the way at limiting offensive players by 11 and 10 percentage points worse than their normal FG%. One thing that stands out is Josh Green, a 6'6 wing, being on both lists. This standout defensive presence should continue to give him opportunities either coming off the bench or starting alongside stars for many years to come. Perhaps Green can become an Alex Caruso-type player for a contender this season.
Three Versatile Defenders, Three Different Profiles
Defensive versatility -- guarding a wide mix of players or actions -- separates elite defenders from good or even great ones. Matchup data lets us check this directly, using data such as the offensive archetypes we assigned in previous analysis (see Offensive Archetypes in the Modern NBA). Offensive players were also grouped into size buckets (based on height), allowing us to see how often players defended guards, wings, and bigs.
I have selected three elite defenders to investigate -- Victor Wembanyama, Ausar Thompson, and Cason Wallace. These players are widely known as one of, if not the best, defender at their respective positions. Let's see if the data agrees.
Points allowed per 100 vs. FG% suppression -- qualified defenders averaging 25+ minutes per game
Victor Wembanyama is the extreme case. He faced all 9 offensive archetypes and 3 size buckets last season, with the single best shot-suppression number of the three (+11.0%, elite) and a strong overall FG% allowed (40.7%, well under the 47.2% league average). However, his points-allowed-per-100 ranks 310th of 337 qualified defenders -- one of the worst matchup numbers in this entire sample. This number alone shows why trusting any single metric is a poor approach to grading defenders. Due to Wemby's aggressive nature and switchability on defense, he may end up as the primary defender for many shot attempts, which in turn increases his points allowed.
This idea is supported when we break down the numbers by the archetype he's guarding. His two worst splits by a wide margin are Initiators (56.9 Pts/100, on a smaller 209-possession sample) and Mid-Post Creators (49.0 Pts/100, 316 possessions) -- both matchups where he's switched onto a smaller, shiftier ball-handler rather than anchored at the rim. His best matchup is Rim Runners (16.5 Pts/100 across a team-high 728 possessions) -- the typical assignment that Wemby will have throughout the game. His length makes shots harder for all opponents anywhere on the court, but the matchups which are worse for him are specifically the ones that pull him away from the basket.
Ausar Thompson and Cason Wallace both rank in the top half of the league on points allowed per 100 possessions (135th and 183rd of 337) and both show modest field-goal suppression (+3.8% and +3.1%). Neither is a top-10 shot-suppressor like Wembanyama, but both limit their opponents from scoring. As expected, their defensive success by archetype is essentially opposite of Wemby's. Both allow their worst points-per-100 number against Post Anchor and Mid-Post Creator matchups -- the bruising, back-to-the-basket archetypes. Thompson allows 39.3 Pts/100 against Post Anchors and 30.0 against Mid-Post Creators; Wallace allows 40.6 and 33.6 on the same two. This shows that even the most elite guard or wing defenders still have problems when matched onto bigger offensive players. However, if you let Thompson and Wallace defend a Shot Creator or an Initiator on an island, they should have no problem shutting that player down.
Does Switching More Make You a Better Defender?
Across a pool of 325 defensive players, the variety of offensive archetypes a player is asked to guard (weighted so facing 9 archetypes evenly scores higher than facing some more than others) correlates with FG% suppression at +0.21 -- more versatile defenders tend to contest shots slightly better. However, versatility correlates with points allowed per 100 at +0.22 too, and that's a positive number in the wrong direction: more versatile defenders actually allow slightly more points per 100, not fewer.
Both relationships are weak, but they don't agree with each other, which fits the pattern from the Leaderboard earlier -- limiting opponents and forcing misses can point in opposite directions for the same player. Versatility alone does not predict quality on either measure. The most archetype-diverse defenders in the league last season (Santi Aldama, Naz Reid, John Collins, Chet Holmgren, among others) include several who grade well below average on one or both outcome metrics -- versatility describes what a defender is asked to do, not how well he does it. Hovering over the graph, the most versatile defenders are on the right, with many being frontcourt players who switch onto the perimeter.
One thing to note -- our measurement of versatility is rooted in guarding multiple offensive archetypes evenly. These archetypes come from prior analysis.
Defensive versatility vs. points allowed per 100 -- qualified defenders averaging 25+ minutes per game
Who Defends Which Archetypes Best
This section combines our defensive stats with the offensive archetypes created previously. Here, we can answer two more specific questions -- who shuts down a given offensive archetype, and which types of offensive players are the best defenders?
Best Defenders Against Each Archetype
Breaking down the matchup data by the offensive archetype of the player being guarded (minimum 150 possessions against that specific archetype to qualify), here's the best defender against each of the 9 offensive archetypes, with the next two behind them:
| Archetype | Defender | Poss | FG% Allowed | Pts/100 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Inside Out Big | Lauri Markkanen | 203.1 | 23.1% | 3.4 |
| LaMelo Ball | 290.0 | 36.0% | 8.3 | |
| Aaron Nesmith | 157.1 | 27.8% | 8.9 | |
| Rim Runner | Zach Edey | 192.7 | 30.8% | 5.2 |
| Clint Capela | 404.1 | 35.3% | 6.9 | |
| Ariel Hukporti | 227.0 | 33.3% | 7.9 | |
| Spot Up Spacer | Jamison Battle | 159.1 | 31.3% | 7.5 |
| Jalen Pickett | 165.1 | 25.0% | 7.9 | |
| Gradey Dick | 432.5 | 23.4% | 8.1 | |
| Movement Shooter | Bilal Coulibaly | 311.7 | 30.6% | 9.3 |
| Amir Coffey | 155.7 | 40.0% | 9.6 | |
| Gary Trent Jr. | 422.2 | 42.9% | 9.7 | |
| Utility Big | Javonte Green | 397.3 | 34.8% | 9.6 |
| Jimmy Butler III | 272.5 | 52.0% | 11.4 | |
| Dylan Harper | 189.8 | 36.0% | 11.6 | |
| Mid-Post Creator | Jayson Tatum | 184.1 | 31.6% | 9.8 |
| Saddiq Bey | 796.6 | 43.1% | 15.8 | |
| Jaylen Brown | 663.5 | 38.0% | 16.4 | |
| Post Anchor | Zach Edey | 150.4 | 31.6% | 10.6 |
| Jordan Walsh | 152.7 | 24.1% | 13.1 | |
| Keldon Johnson | 269.4 | 27.9% | 13.4 | |
| Shot Creator | Christian Braun | 498.0 | 25.9% | 12.0 |
| Jalen Pickett | 377.9 | 34.0% | 12.4 | |
| Tyrese Martin | 389.1 | 32.1% | 12.9 | |
| Initiator | Drake Powell | 285.9 | 38.2% | 12.9 |
| Amen Thompson | 1258.6 | 39.3% | 14.8 | |
| Herbert Jones | 695.5 | 32.4% | 15.0 |
The ordering of the archetypes themselves tells its own story. Even the single best defender in the league against Initiators -- the highest-usage, most shot-creating and playmaking archetype there is -- still allows 12.9 Pts/100, nearly 4 points higher than the best defender against any other archetype. Shutting down a primary playmaker who can generate his own offense is a fundamentally harder defensive job than shutting down any other type of offensive player, no matter who's doing the guarding.
Zach Edey shows up twice, as the best defender against both Rim Runners and Post Anchors -- the two most traditionally "big man" offensive roles, which is exactly the kind of result you'd expect from a 7'4" center. Less expected: Lauri Markkanen, an offensive-minded forward, posts the single best number against any archetype in this entire breakdown (3.4 Pts/100 against Inside Out Bigs), though on a smaller 203-possession sample than most of the names above him.
Best Defenders, By Their Own Archetype
Flip the question around: instead of looking at who a defender is guarding, look at what kind of offensive player the defender himself is (his own offensive archetype, from the archetype clustering). This tells us which offensive archetype is typically the best at defense. When filtering for players who guarded at least 1,500 possessions in 2025-2026, 336 defenders qualify for this analysis:
| Own Archetype | Qualified Defenders | Avg Pts/100 Allowed | Best Defender in Group (Pts/100) | Best Defender in Group (FG% Suppression) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mid-Post Creator | 31 | 22.0 | Amen Thompson (15.4) | Victor Wembanyama (+11.0%) |
| Initiator | 35 | 22.4 | Norman Powell (18.0) | Shai Gilgeous-Alexander (+5.0%) |
| Movement Shooter | 44 | 22.5 | Klay Thompson (16.2) | Gradey Dick (+4.8%) |
| Shot Creator | 67 | 22.5 | Caleb Love (16.4) | Vince Williams Jr. (+4.2%) |
| Spot Up Spacer | 46 | 23.7 | Josh Green (16.1) | Josh Green (+6.8%) |
| Utility Big | 34 | 26.0 | Keldon Johnson (18.2) | Isaiah Stewart (+7.0%) |
| Inside Out Big | 33 | 26.5 | Harrison Barnes (19.0) | Jaylin Williams (+6.8%) |
| Post Anchor | 22 | 28.1 | Giannis Antetokounmpo (18.6) | Chet Holmgren (+8.0%) |
| Rim Runner | 24 | 29.7 | Jericho Sims (22.3) | Clint Capela (+10.0%) |
The real split here is size. Rim Runner and Post Anchor, the two most traditionally "big man" offensive archetypes, give up more points per 100 possessions than the other archetypes. Even when we look at Utility Big and Inside Out Big as well, these four primarily big-man driven offensive playstyles give up at least 26 points per 100 possessions, compared to 23.7 or lower for more wing- or guard-oriented playstyles. This doesn't mean that bigs are worse defenders. It can simply mean that they are put in more disadvantageous matchups when having to guard the perimeter, or it's just more difficult to defend the rim than it is to defend a jumpshot (due to the proximity of the shot). It's worth noting Post Anchor is the smallest qualifying group at 22, so that average rests on a thinner sample than the rest.
Three of the best-in-group names are stars who aren't usually the first names mentioned in "best individual defender" conversations -- Harrison Barnes, Norman Powell, and Klay Thompson all post the lowest Pts/100 allowed among players who share their own offensive archetype last season. Barnes and Klay showing up here is a testament to their defensive IQ shining through, even past their athletic prime.
The suppression column tells a different story. The best shot-suppressors within each archetype are typically bigger, more inside-oriented players. Victor Wembanyama (+11.0%), Clint Capela (+10.0%), and Chet Holmgren (+8.0%) lead the way, even though the big-man archetypes allow the most points per 100 possessions as a group. This matches what we saw previously -- bigs make shots harder without necessarily leading in points allowed. Josh Green is the one name who tops his group on both measures, as the best Spot Up Spacer in both Pts/100 and suppression.
Best Defenders Against the League's Top Scorers
One thing not considered yet is matchup quality. A defender can perform well against average or bad offensive players and top the leaderboards shown earlier. Here, we look at who shuts down the best offensive players in the league. Taking the top 20 scorers by points per game last season (min. 20 games played, ranging from Luka Dončić at 33.5 down to Pascal Siakam at 24.0), here's the toughest defender for each one.
Use the toggle to switch to the defender who held that scorer furthest below his usual shooting percentage instead. For that view, FG% suppression means the scorer's field goal percentage against everyone, minus his field goal percentage against this defender (the defender needed at least 6 FGA defended against the offensive player). Keep in mind that these are small samples since only last season was used for the matchup data.
A player who continues to stand out is Amen Thompson. He is the toughest individual matchup, by points allowed per 100, for 4 of the 20 highest-scoring players in the league (Luka Dončić, Donovan Mitchell, Stephen Curry, and Jalen Brunson), and no one else tops the list more than once. Switch to FG% suppression and Thompson still appears twice (Dončić and Curry), tied with Andrew Wiggins and Isaac Okoro for the most. These are four elite guards, and Thompson continues to make his case for best perimeter defender in the league (more on him to come as well).
That pattern still holds up when pooling each defender's full workload against the entire top-20 group. Restricting to defenders with at least 150 total possessions against this specific pool of 20 scorers, here are the ten with the fewest points allowed per 100:
| Defender | Poss vs. Top 20 | # of Top 20 Faced | FG% Allowed | Pts/100 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ousmane Dieng | 161.6 | 12 | 27.3% | 16.1 |
| Amen Thompson | 731.3 | 19 | 42.7% | 20.1 |
| LeBron James | 194.0 | 15 | 39.0% | 20.1 |
| Marcus Smart | 462.8 | 19 | 48.6% | 21.8 |
| Herbert Jones | 613.5 | 17 | 48.5% | 22.2 |
| Jordan Walsh | 288.5 | 15 | 39.3% | 22.2 |
| Quentin Grimes | 196.6 | 15 | 34.0% | 22.4 |
| Drake Powell | 159.3 | 15 | 43.3% | 22.6 |
| Saddiq Bey | 397.2 | 18 | 45.8% | 22.7 |
| Alex Caruso | 290.6 | 16 | 36.8% | 23.1 |
Amen Thompson is one of the names on this list who faced almost the entire pool (19 of the 20 highest scorers, along with Marcus Smart), with by far the largest possession volume here at 731, while still allowing 20.1 Pts/100, essentially tied for second best with LeBron James. Ousmane Dieng's number is the best of the ten, but on a much smaller sample (12 of the 20, 162 possessions) than anyone else in this table, and LeBron's rests on only 194 possessions. Thompson is shutting down the best scorers night after night.
Creating Defensive Archetypes (2017-18 to 2025-26)
Everything above comes from matchup and shot-tracking data directly -- no model involved. This section is different. I used a clustering model that groups defenders into actual defensive archetypes, the same way we grouped players into offensive playstyles. With fewer meaningful metrics available on defense and more ambiguous roles for defenders, this analysis did not lead to as clean of a split as it does for offense. Multiple attempts were needed to arrive at the final result, but it isn't perfect.
Unlike everything above, which looks only at last season (2025-26), the defensive archetypes are built from nine seasons of data (2017-18 through 2025-26) pooled together. Every qualifying player-season is its own data point, so a defender can appear up to nine times, and can land in a different archetype in different seasons if his role changes. The top-defender table below is filtered back down to last season, but the clusters themselves come from all nine years.
The first attempt grouped every defender in the league together, regardless of position. The model decided on 7 defensive clusters (archetypes) based on two things -- what kind of possessions a player defends and how well he defends them. The clusters barely separated from each other, and players often landed in different clusters when re-running the model. There was no consistency in this approach, so we could not determine which archetype a player truly belonged in.
The second attempt tried to fix that by discounting small samples -- a center who'd only defended 10 possessions against a shot creator had his data pulled toward the league average instead of treated as real signal -- and by raising the bar for which players qualified at all. That's good statistical practice which stayed in the final version, but it didn't fix the instability. The clusters were still unreliable.
The third attempt dropped style entirely and clustered on quality alone to find how good players are at defense. This was an attempt to cluster players into defensive tiers, with the hope of determining elite, great, good, average, and bad defenders. Unfortunately, the only somewhat reliable result was 2 groupings -- good and bad.
The actual fix was splitting defenders into Guards, Wings, and Bigs first, by height, and running the clustering separately within each group. Height was driving every result in the first three attempts, so this eliminated that possibility. Having three clusters within each height group turned out to be highly stable: refitting the model 10 times with different random seeds, players land in the same cluster essentially every time.
That gave nine defensive archetypes, three per height group:
- Guards: Physical Point-of-Attack Guard, Playmaker-Defending Guard, Pure Perimeter Guard
- Wings: Perimeter Point-of-Attack Wing, Small-Ball Five Wing, Combo-Forward Wing
- Bigs: Rim Anchor, Switchable Stretch Big, Full-Switch Big
What does each defensive archetype mean? (click to expand)
Guards (6'5" and under)
- Physical Point-of-Attack Guard: a pesky, physical on-ball guard. Draws more charges and boxes out more than any other guard, and gets more matchups against bigger offensive players (post creators and bigs) than other guards do.
- Playmaker-Defending Guard: the all-around guard, and the most common guard type by far. No extreme trait; more than half of his possessions are against guards, with a steady diet of ball-handlers.
- Pure Perimeter Guard: stays on the perimeter. Rarely guards Rim Runners or Post Anchors (about 7% of possessions combined, versus 44% for Rim Anchors) and spends the most time on Shot Creators (35% of possessions).
Wings (6'6" to 6'9")
- Perimeter Point-of-Attack Wing: the wing who gets the ball-handler and shot-creator assignments. Guards more Initiators and Shot Creators than other wings and chases shooters through handoffs and off-screens. The most common wing archetype.
- Small-Ball Five Wing: wing-sized, but the possessions look like a center's: heavy on Rim Runners and Post Anchors (about 32% combined), and far more box-outs than other wings. In practice these are undersized bigs.
- Combo-Forward Wing: the positionless forward who guards a bit of everything, inside and out. Draws a lot of charges and sees more bigs and spot-up shooters than the point-of-attack wings do.
Bigs (6'10" and up)
- Rim Anchor: the traditional center. Spends the most time against Rim Runners and Post Anchors (24% and 20% of possessions) and stays closest to the basket.
- Switchable Stretch Big: a big who leaves the paint some. His possessions skew toward handoffs, movement shooters, initiators and mid-post creators, so he spends more time defending in space than a Rim Anchor.
- Full-Switch Big: the big who leaves the paint the most. What separates him from the Stretch Big is pick-and-roll ball-handlers: he defends them more than any other big, on top of handoffs, off-screen shooters and spot-up shooters. It is also the smallest group (85 of 2,854 player-seasons).
The difference between the last two is one of degree, not a clean break: both are bigs who defend away from the basket. If a Stretch Big is a big who sometimes steps out, a Full-Switch Big is one who regularly guards the opposing guard's pick-and-roll.
A small number of players don't stay in one cluster across reruns -- 42 out of 2,854 qualifying player-seasons, about 1.5%. Almost all of them are Wings switching between Perimeter Point-of-Attack Wing and Combo-Forward Wing: Draymond Green, Pascal Siakam, Aaron Gordon, Zion Williamson, Scottie Barnes, among others. These are players whose role genuinely shifts between guarding the ball on the perimeter and guarding a bigger forward inside, and the model is picking that up rather than just disagreeing with itself.
Scoring Defenders Within Each Archetype
The archetypes above describe style -- what kind of defender someone is by the responsibility they have. The archetypes don't say anything about who's good at it. For that, we built a formula for each of the nine archetypes, weighted toward the things that matter most for defense: how much they suppress shooters' field goal percentage and points allowed per 100 possessions, activity stats like contests and deflections, how often they actually guard various playstyles and actions, and a small availability check so an end-of-bench player can't top the list on a tiny sample.
Here's the top defender in each archetype, last season (2025-26):
| Archetype | Defender | Score | FG% Suppression | Pts/100 (own blend) | MIN | GP |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Physical Point-of-Attack Guard | Marcus Smart | 100.0 | +3.8% | 21.6 | 28.5 | 62 |
| Playmaker-Defending Guard | Ayo Dosunmu | 100.0 | +2.3% | 18.7 | 27.3 | 69 |
| Pure Perimeter Guard | Matisse Thybulle | 100.0 | +8.1% | 19.3 | 16.0 | 30 |
| Perimeter Point-of-Attack Wing | Amen Thompson | 100.0 | +4.3% | 16.8 | 37.4 | 79 |
| Small-Ball Five Wing | Bam Adebayo | 100.0 | +2.4% | 24.8 | 32.4 | 73 |
| Combo-Forward Wing | Josh Green | 100.0 | +6.8% | 18.8 | 15.7 | 58 |
| Rim Anchor | Chet Holmgren | 100.0 | +8.0% | 24.3 | 28.9 | 69 |
| Switchable Stretch Big | Mouhamed Gueye | 100.0 | +5.6% | 24.9 | 15.3 | 77 |
| Full-Switch Big | Brook Lopez | 100.0 | +5.8% | 26.6 | 21.8 | 75 |
Amen Thompson's name continues to show up, further supporting the idea that he is one of the best defenders in the NBA. Chet Holmgren topping Rim Anchor aligns with what the matchup data already suggested too. The limitations of this approach are also on display, as Bam Adebayo is listed as the best Small-Ball Five Wing. While Adebayo is short for the center position, he is not a wing, but his height grouped him in with the wings for this analysis.
Who Defends Well Year After Year
The results above are a one-year snapshot, and a defender who performs well once could be a one-year fluke. The within-archetype score from the last section exists for every season in the dataset, so we can check who repeatedly scores near the top of their own archetype. Here are the ten best average scores among defenders with at least six qualifying seasons (the score runs from 0 to 100, where 100 is the best defender in that archetype that season; the typical defender averages a score of 52):
| Defender | Seasons | Avg Score | Lowest Season | Seasons at 75+ | Archetypes Held |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Matisse Thybulle | 6 | 92.0 | 79.4 | 6 of 6 | 3 |
| Draymond Green | 9 | 89.2 | 75.4 | 9 of 9 | 2 |
| Giannis Antetokounmpo | 9 | 88.4 | 63.4 | 8 of 9 | 3 |
| Bam Adebayo | 9 | 88.0 | 47.5 | 8 of 9 | 3 |
| Marcus Smart | 8 | 83.0 | 55.4 | 5 of 8 | 1 |
| Kevin Durant | 8 | 82.9 | 64.4 | 5 of 8 | 4 |
| Ben Simmons | 6 | 82.5 | 59.2 | 3 of 6 | 3 |
| LeBron James | 9 | 81.9 | 55.8 | 7 of 9 | 3 |
| P.J. Tucker | 7 | 81.3 | 51.3 | 4 of 7 | 2 |
| Luguentz Dort | 7 | 80.8 | 49.9 | 6 of 7 | 2 |
Draymond Green is the clearest example of lasting defensive value. He scored 75 or higher in all nine seasons, and his worst year (75.4) is better than most players' average. Giannis Antetokounmpo and Bam Adebayo are right behind him, each at about 88 on average, though Adebayo's lowest year (47.5) shows that elite defenders can have a down season. Marcus Smart (83.0), Kevin Durant (82.9), and LeBron James (81.9) are the next names above 80. Matisse Thybulle tops the list on average, but he typically plays limited minutes, and the formulas for scoring defenders only take this into consideration slightly. Thybulle is known league-wide as a premier defender, but this is just worth noting.
How Defensive Roles Change Over Time
Because the archetypes are assigned one season at a time, we can follow a player from year to year and see whether his defensive role changes. Across 1,911 pairs of consecutive qualifying seasons, a player stayed in the same archetype 61% of the time. There are 4% of defenders who actually changed height group (guard, wing, or big), meaning the defensive archetypes they were eligible for also changed.
How stable a role is depends heavily on where the player starts:
| Archetype (Season 1) | Stayed Next Season |
|---|---|
| Playmaker-Defending Guard | 75% |
| Perimeter Point-of-Attack Wing | 73% |
| Small-Ball Five Wing | 69% |
| Rim Anchor | 55% |
| Physical Point-of-Attack Guard | 53% |
| Combo-Forward Wing | 48% |
| Switchable Stretch Big | 38% |
| Pure Perimeter Guard | 35% |
| Full-Switch Big | 25% |
The archetypes that sit between two extremes are the least stable. Full-Switch Big and Switchable Stretch Big are both "bigs who sometimes defend like wings," and players in these roles tend to switch back and forth with the Rim Runner archetype. The same story exists among wings. The most common move in the entire dataset is a Perimeter Point-of-Attack Wing becoming a Combo-Forward Wing (86 times), and the second most common is the reverse (72 times). Only 17% of players with five or more qualifying seasons stayed in one archetype the whole time, and a third of them had at least three archetypes.
A few well-known careers show the different ways this plays out:
| Player | Path |
|---|---|
| Jayson Tatum | Perimeter Point-of-Attack Wing in all 8 qualifying seasons (2017-18 to 2024-25) |
| Bam Adebayo | Rim Anchor (2017-18), Switchable Stretch Big (2018-19), then Small-Ball Five Wing every year since 2019-20 |
| Draymond Green | Swings between Combo-Forward Wing and Small-Ball Five Wing; Small-Ball Five Wing for the last three seasons |
| LeBron James | Moves between Combo-Forward Wing and Perimeter Point-of-Attack Wing, with a one-year Small-Ball Five Wing stint in 2023-24 |
| Kevin Durant | Perimeter Point-of-Attack Wing (2017-19), Full-Switch Big (2020-21), Switchable Stretch Big (2021-25), Rim Anchor (2025-26) |
Durant's path comes with a caveat. His listed height went from 6'9" to 6'10" between 2018-19 and 2020-21, which moved him from the Wing group to the Big group. Part of his "role change" is simply that he could no longer be placed in the 3 wing archetypes, not necessarily a change in who he guards or how he defends. That is a limit of splitting by height first (we also saw this with Bam Adebayo).
Explore Defensive Archetypes and Scores Over Time
The tables above are snapshots. These tools below let you dig into the full nine seasons of defensive archetypes and scores yourself: pick a season and archetype to see who ranked where, or look up any player to see how his archetype and score changed from year to year. Scores are the within-archetype, within-season scores from earlier (100 is the best defender in that archetype that season, and each score is only compared to players in the same archetype and season).
The scores may not align with public perception or overall defensive talent. They are specific to the archetype and the role that archetype has individually.
Loading defender data...
Loading defender data...
Pts/100 here is the blended figure used in the top-defender table earlier, so it can differ slightly from the matchup-ledger Pts/100 on the Leaderboard. FG% Suppression is higher = better. A player only appears in seasons where he qualified for the defensive archetype analysis.
Takeaways
Defense is a complex part of basketball that can be measured in many ways. Players' roles on defense and nightly responsibilities play a large part in how they are viewed and the success they have. Finding the "best" defenders isn't a simple task. Metrics that may be used for this don't always align with each other, meaning that you have to take multiple things into consideration when assessing someone's defense. Ultimately, how you view a defender will come down to what you value the most, whether that is limiting scoring, holding opponents to a bad field-goal %, getting blocks and steals, or whatever else it may be.